Does the Mercedes GLE 450 Hold Value Better Than the BMW X5?
Yes, the Mercedes GLE 450 is the better choice for holding value. After 5 years, the GLE 450 retains 46.5% of its original price, while the BMW X5 retains only 41.1%. This means you'll lose less money when you sell or trade in the Mercedes.
Value Retention Comparison
Here's how the two SUVs stack up over 5 years:
| Metric | Mercedes GLE 450 | BMW X5 |
|---|---|---|
| 5-Year Depreciation | 53.5% | 58.9% |
| Value Retained | 46.5% | 41.1% |
| Advantage | Holds 5.4% more value | Lower starting price |
Starting Prices
The GLE 450 starts around $72,500, while the BMW X5 entry-level models begin near $65,700 to $68,000. Even though the X5 costs less upfront, the GLE 450's better resale value helps close that gap over time.
What This Means for Your Budget
If you buy a $72,500 GLE 450, you'll have roughly $33,600 in resale value after 5 years. A $68,000 BMW X5 would be worth about $27,900 after the same period. Over five years, the GLE 450's stronger resale value saves you money despite the higher purchase price.
Luxury SUVs typically lose significant value in their first year. Both vehicles take a major hit initially, but the Mercedes slows its depreciation curve afterward. This pattern is common across the luxury midsize SUV category.
Beyond Resale Value
While depreciation matters, consider other ownership costs too. The BMW X5 offers more horsepower from its base engine (483 hp vs. 381 hp), which some drivers prefer. Insurance, maintenance, and fuel costs can also vary between models and should factor into your decision.
When comparing these two SUVs, the Mercedes GLE 450 wins on value retention. But weigh this advantage against your priorities for performance, features, and overall driving experience.